When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Heres how it works.

Last week during my brief sojourn away from work, Microsoft debuted its new ad campaign for Xbox.

I even wrote an editorial last week abouthow Microsoft has some amazing Xbox momentum as it closes out 2024.

Microsoft�s "This is an Xbox" ad campaign with "apparently" attached to it in parody.

Microsoft says a bunch of devices that can’t run 99% of Xbox games are Xboxes, apparently.

I love that there are dozens of games that support cross-buy and cross-progression via Xbox Play Anywhere.

The issue is that it’s so,sopiecemeal.

I’ve also written only recently about how theXbox app experience on Windows PC is still sub-par.

This is an Xbox

Microsoft’s “This is an Xbox” campaign patronizingly showcases products that aren’t an Xbox for some reason.

The big claim earned an immediate grimace from me in multiple directions.

What is the general public, to whom this is targeted, supposed to take away from this claim?

Has Xbox itself forgotten what an Xbox actually is?

Microsoft mock up detailing partnership ads “This is an Xbox” with Samsung, showcasing Samsung devices.

Even still, it’s not like any of those features are actually showcased in this ad here.

What game can you realistically play from yourlapon the Xbox app anyway?

Am I expected to run Halo Infinite ranked with the trackpad here?

Diablo 4 Vessel of Hatred on the Logitech G Cloud delivered by Nvidia GeForce Now

Even some of Microsoft’s own games, like Diablo 4, aren’t available on Xbox Cloud Gaming thanks to licensing commitments —at least today.

All this is without mentioning the fact that it barely runs any Xbox games.

In what timeline, realistically, is a Samsung Galaxy Fold an Xbox?

Certainly not the one I’m living in.

Xbox - This Is an Xbox - YouTube

Why is Microsoft confusing people into not buying an Xbox in the run up to Christmas?

you could argue the execution has been less-than-stellar though.

“I’m not sure I’d have a particularly compelling answer for them.

Xbox Play Anywhere with a thinking emoji

The Xbox game store for Android and iOS was supposed to launch this quarter, but now isn’t.

Like I said earlier, the vision is awesome.

The vision is excellent.

Xbox app with Final Fantasy III displayed

But why market to avisionthat isn’t fully realized?

Why denigrate the premiere Xbox experience as it exists today?

Theonly placewhere you might get a true, full-fat Xbox experience is Xbox Series X|S.

Phil Spencer on Gamertag Radio in Jan 2025

It showcases where Xbox is going.

It showcases what the future of gaming in general will look like.

Microsoft is good at predicting the future.

Activision Blizzard character heroes

Ten years later, people are increasingly preferring all-digital.

The problem is, like in 2013, you’re free to’t tell people what theyshouldlike orshouldwant.

I love the direction Microsoft is heading towards.

Monument Valley image

We’re years away from that future, if indeed it materializes at all.

I have faith that it will, but we’re nowhere near there right now.

So why tell every day people that Xbox has already reached that destination?

Age of Empires 2: Definitive Edition The Three Kingdoms DLC art

Microsoft’s “This is an Xbox” ad campaign is great on paper.

It’s just absolutely the wrong time to be making the claim.

The vast majority of developers opt out of Xbox Play Anywhere between PC and Xbox.

Xbox controller with WD-40

The vast majority PC developers don’t support the Microsoft Store ecosystem without a Game Pass tie-in.

Banjo Kazooie Smash

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

The Elder Scrolls Online 2025 Daedra battle

Razer�s Minecraft collection in retail boxes

Call of Duty: Warzone returns to its roots with Verdansk map for Season 3.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2025)

Witchbrook first look screenshots.

Minecraft�s new key art.

Inspecting the Kilo 141 in Call of Duty: Black Ops 6